Analyze Hacker News Launch Feedback by Thread
Use a Hacker News item ID to retrieve a bounded comment tree. Read parent and child replies together before counting independent reports or assigning a product follow-up.
Documentation reviewed: 2026-11-14 · By PostToData
Find the discussion before reading replies
Use the item ID from news.ycombinator.com/item?id=…. For a known discussion, one comments call is the starting point. Look up post details separately only if you need the original launch framing.
Rebuild the branch from the export
Use JSON to keep parent_id and depth when available. The November 11 recording includes an assertion about XML versus JSON followed by a reader asking why and another offering an explanation. Those three rows form one branch. Preserve comment URLs when a truncated export omits a parent.
Write a triage item with a verification step
For launch feedback, use columns for observation, parent context, reproducibility and owner. Move an install failure to engineering only after capturing the environment and steps. Put a design question in documentation review with the branch link.
Example sources and documentation
Current prices & implemented operations
| Operation | Per successful call | 1,000 successful calls |
|---|---|---|
| Hacker News · Comments | $0.001 | $1.00 |
| Hacker News · Post detail | $0.001 | $1.00 |
The 1,000-call figure is list price multiplied by calls, not 1,000 records or a top-up package. The example only previews the first operation: no upstream fetch or charge. To retrieve data, remove dry_run=1 and supply Authorization: Bearer API_KEY. Keep max_price_usd to reject a price above the approved amount.
curl --get "https://posttodata.com/v1/hackernews/comments" \
--data-urlencode 'id=44404905' \
--data-urlencode 'limit=5' \
--data-urlencode 'max_price_usd=0.001' \
--data-urlencode 'dry_run=1'A per-call ceiling is not a shared budget for the whole task. Bound the number of approved calls and stop on 402, 412 or 429; do not automatically raise limits or rotate accounts.
Frequently asked questions
Should a nested reply count as a second report?
Count it separately only if it describes a distinct observation. A question or agreement can add context to the first report.
Related guides
- Read Replies to an X Post with MCP
- Review Instagram Giveaway Comments in a Spreadsheet
- Use Bilibili Tutorial Comments to Find Corrections
- Export YouTube Comments to CSV or Excel